Using Technology: Wrong and Right (or Play and Think)

I pretty much dislike right/wrong dichotomies (things in life are rarely black and white), but this graphic posted by Bill Ferriter (@plugusin) on Twitter is worth sharing and briefly commenting on.

rightandwrong

I like the question, “What do you want kids to do with technology?” because the answer will show whether the thinking is stuck in the “technology tool quicksand” or developed to the point of “learning outcomes” as the final sentence puts rather well, “Technology is a tool, not a learning outcome.”

I’m struggling with the headings of the columns. Here’s why… You need the “wrong” column to get to the “right” column. And the “right” column is definitely what we want people to do…and with technology…otherwise we’re living in an analog world. The problem with the thinking of educators (and largely our professional development) is that we too often stop at the “wrong” column. Because to move to the “right” column means we have to CHANGE the way we do the “right” column (if we ever did it at all!).

The tools in the “wrong” column (and there are countless more) shouldn’t (and can’t) be totally discounted, or labeled “wrong.” We need them, and more, if we want to get to the “right” column. We need technology tools if we want to THINK with technology.  Those of us who get this need to figure out how to influence others to think beyond the “wrong” and get to the “right.”

All that being said, how would you relabel the columns? Initially, I was thinking PLAY and THINK, but does that unfairly characterize PLAY? Do we need to PLAY before or while we THINK?

Advertisements

4 comments on “Using Technology: Wrong and Right (or Play and Think)

  1. I really do like this list! Both actually. And it shows how important it is to get to this mind shift … The labeling isn’t optimal, I agree. What about: USE // to SHOW YOUR THINKING.

  2. Pingback: What do you want ‪#‎kids‬ to do with ‪#‎technology‬? | #DeleteCyberbullying

  3. How about Create for the Left and Impact for Right? Technology is more then a tool as that discounts the many forms of technology. Using Technology for the sake of using it is as wrong as never using it. I think the concepts of SAMR and TPACK help to shift the disucssion towards academics instead of devotion to technology no matter what we call it. Good post.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s